Theft of Property in Unlocked Cars in Rumson Leads to Burglary Charges, Lack of Force Entry Does Not Negate the Crime.
After a month of nearly a dozen car break-ins, Matthew Mennillow, 31 of Toms River, and Lisa Clayton, 25, of Berkeley were arrested in Manchestor on nine counts of burglary, theft, and a count of criminal attempt to commit burglary.
According to the police report, all of the vehicles were unlocked and the suspects are accused of stealing about $1,800 in property. Most of the property consisted of cash, credit/debit cards, and GPS units. Police used surveillance video to find Mennilow and Clayton.
A burglary occurs when one 1) breaks into and 2) enters 3) a building or car 4) without consent and 5) with the intent to commit a felony or steal property.
In early common law, burglarly laws applied only to homes and only if it occurred at night. Under current law however, burglary laws have extended to many structures, even portabe ones like cars, boats, and mobile homes. Furthermore, burlarly used to require a forcible breaking and entry. Thus, under common law the two defendants discussed above would not have been able to be found guilty because the cars were unlocked. Under modern law any entry can constitute burglary, For example, even if the car windows were rolled down and the defendants simply put their arm through the window to grab the property it would still constitute burglary (assuming all of the other elements of the law are met)

